Books etc. about carnal child pollution and abuse by clergy, brothers, sisters, etc.


• Oranges and Sunshine.  [MOVIE.]     

Oranges and Sunshine

   Disassociated.com , (the website and online notepad of Sydney based blogger John Lampard), <http://­ww­w.disassociated.com/­2011/06/10/oranges-and-sunshine/>, posted by John Lampard at 11:04 am on Friday, 10 June, 2011
4 stars
The premise
   Oranges and Sunshine, movie Oranges and Sunshine (trailer), a drama set in 1986, is the debut feature of British TV producer Jim Loach, and is based on the book Empty Cradles by British social worker Margaret Humphreys, which chronicles her efforts to expose the British government’s child migrants program of the 1950s and 60s, [actually started before 1950s] where over 130,000 children were forcibly sent overseas.
   Many of these children – who came from struggling, or single-parent families, and were sent to Australia, and other former British colonies – were under the impression their parents were dead, and that a happier life awaited them elsewhere.  The reality was usually far harsher, many were abused by their new carers, or became child labourers.
The play
   Humphreys (Emily Watson) is a Nottingham social worker caring for orphaned children.  She first becomes aware British children were sent overseas when a woman from Australia [in 1986] asks for help tracing her mother.  During this investigation though Humphreys uncovers numerous instances of children being sent overseas.
   After learning that Nicky (Lorraine Ashbourne), a woman in a support group she convenes, has a brother Jack (Hugo Weaving), who was sent overseas as a child, Humphreys travels to Australia where she soon meets many hundreds of others who were taken from their families, including Len (David Wenham), who is trying to find his mother.
   It soon becomes apparent that it wasn’t just the children who were lied to, and as Humphreys continues to reunite now adult children with their families, she learns the parents, whose children were often forcibly removed from their custody, were also lied to, often being told they had been adopted locally, not sent overseas.
   Humphreys’ work however is an uphill battle that takes a physical and emotional toll on her.  The British and Australian governments are unhelpful, while the charity and church groups who took the children in are angered by the allegations of abuse levelled at them, resulting in threats against her from their supporters.
The wrap
   “Oranges and Sunshine” is an intimate and personal portrayal of an historical episode that culminated with the 2009 apology by then Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, to the British child migrants, or Forgotten Australians as they are also known, an action that was followed by his British counterpart, Gordon Brown, in 2010.
   A compassionately made film that is neither sentimental or sensationalistic, “Oranges and Sunshine” is a moving, harrowing, and emotional drama that lifts the lid on a government policy that aimed simply to save money – care for children was cheaper in Australia than Britain – and one that had no regard at all for those it purported to be helping. #

   [OTHER LINK/S: <http://­www.abc.net.au/­atthemovies/txt­/s3230720.htm>, <http://­www.imdb.com/­title/tt1438216/>, <http://­www.sixteenfilms.co.uk/­films/film/oranges_­and_sunshine/>, and watch the trailer at <www.orange­sandsuns­hine.co­m.au>. ENDS.]
   [MORE READING: The West Australian, Tuesday, June 14, 2011, Today section page 8, "Pain of empty cradles" by Lucy Gibson, the story of "Oranges and Sunshine" star Emily Watson who plays the Nottingham social worker Margaret Humphreys, and "Into the heart of darkness," a review of the film, some of which focussed on Bindoon in Western Australia. 
   Margaret Humphreys, who wrote Empty Cradles about what we now call the "Forgotten Children," is quoted as saying that more than 150,000 children were shipped to the outer reaches of the British Commonwealth.  The film is now screening in Perth, Western Australia. ENDS.]
http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/carnalbooks.htm#oranges-and-sunshine
http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont180.htm#oranges-and-sunshine
http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/religion/religchron5.htm#oranges-and-sunshine
[Jun 10, 2011]
  Catholics admit "gag"  Reports from 1978  ^ ^  Broken Rites (Australia)  Irish Survivors' Links  Bishop Accountability (USA)  Celibacy crept  Non-Marital  REFERENCES 15   121  Overview  Outreach  Books  v v   Anglican checks  Betrayal "Fathers"  Secrecy  Petition 
 Directories:  Main 20  Australia 2  Esperanto  Experiments  Freedom  Georgist  Globalism  Molestation 148  Religion 2  Submission 7 
http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/carnalbooks.htm

Charles Lewis: an interview with authors of new book on sexual abuse in Canadian Catholic Church

  [BOOK – HIGGINS, Michael W., and KAVANAGH, Peter. 2010. Suffer The Children Unto Me. RCC.]  
   National Post, <http://­life.nationalpost.com/­2010/11/01/charles-lewis-an-interview-with-authors-of-new-book-on-sexual-abuse-in-canadian-catholic-church>; Charles Lewis, November 1, 2010
   Suffer the children unto me; Michael W. HIGGINS, and Peter KAVANAGH; http://arts.nationalpost.com CANADA - Toronto-based Novalis publishing has just released Suffer The Children Unto Me by Canadian journalists Michael W. Higgins and Peter Kavanagh. The book examines the sexual abuse crisis in the Canadian Roman Catholic Church and puts it in the context of the problems occurring in the global Church. It also focuses heavily on the media coverage of the Church and whether it was really fair and balanced.
   It is worth noting that both authors are practicing Catholics and Novalis is a Catholic publishing house. Mr. Kavanagh noted that his personal faith was not an impediment to writing the book since inequity wherever it takes place is something that needs to be addressed. Mr. Higgins said that as a Catholic, writing about the sins of the Church was a "painful experience." But neither man felt their faith hindered their objectivity.
   On Monday I sat down with the authors to discuss some of the findings of their book as well as related issues. A full book review will appear on this site in the next few weeks.
   HP: Former Supreme Court justice Michel Bastarache delivered his confidential recommendations to a New Brunswick diocese on Monday about what would be appropriate compensation for local victims of sexual abuse. In Antigonish last year the diocese there paid out $13-million in compensation. That financial burden left a lot of resentment among parishioners who felt they were being punished for the sins of others and it has created a terrible problem for local parishes. Is financial compensation the best way to deal with victims?
   PK: In modern times this is how you resolve issues. You decide there's been a wrong and right it through cash, which is a legal response. All kinds of people say the people [of] Antigonish shouldn't have to pay for this. But the way the Church is structured, the diocese has the legal obligation. It's not good or bad, it's just the way it is. People will feel hard done by for something they're not responsible for. Think of this outside of a Church situation: if a secular institution does wrong, it is the members of that institution that end bearing the cost. Every wrongful conviction in this country {for example} has required the outlay of significant amounts of money out of taxpayers' pockets. And even though those taxpayers did nothing wrong, they have to bear the cost. Posted by Kathy Shaw on November 1, 2010 7:35 PM
   [BOOK REVIEW: <http://­arts.nationalpost.com/­2010/11/19/­book-review-suffer-the-children-unto-me-by-michael-w-higgins-and-peter-kavanagh/>  [2010]

Respected expert to talk on Catholic church future

  [BOOK – ALLEN, John. The Future Church: How Ten Trends are Revolutionizing the Catholic Church. RCC.]  
   Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, <http://­www.post-gazette.com/­pg/10305/1099694-455.stm>, By Ann Rodgers, Monday, November 01, 2010
   PENNSYLVANIA -- John Allen, a renowned reporter on Vatican affairs for both the National Catholic Reporter and CNN, will speak in the Pittsburgh region Wednesday, and again on Nov. 11.
   He will speak Wednesday night in McCandless, and on Nov. 11 he will give a six-hour seminar at the Villa Maria Community Center in Villa Maria, Lawrence County. Both draw from his book, "The Future Church: How Ten Trends are Revolutionizing the Catholic Church." …
   Americans' concerns are important, "but if we are going to be part of the global family, we need to think bigger about what the challenges facing us are," he said.
   One example of a disconnect is a call from the advocates for victims of sexual abuse for Pope Benedict XVI to expand the reporting requirement in the United States to the entire world. Reporting sex crimes to the police is the right policy in the U.S., where the police are generally honest and the rights of Catholics are respected, Mr. Allen said. But it could be disastrous in nations where the police are complicit in persecution of the Catholic Church. An abuse report could bring violent attacks on the entire Catholic community.
   "You can understand why Catholics in such places aren't eager to cooperate with the police. A mandate to do so would seem to them like a death sentence," Mr. Allen said. Posted by Kathy Shaw on November 1, 2010 7:48 AM

Two books look at clergy sex abuse crisis

  [BOOKS. RCC]  
   Catholic San Francisco, http://www.catholic-sf.org/news_select.php?newsid=10&id=57699 , By Brian T. Olszewski, October 13th, 2010
   "WHEN VALUES COLLIDE: THE CATHOLIC CHURCH, SEXUAL ABUSE AND THE CHALLENGES OF LEADERSHIP" by Joseph P. Chinnici. Orbis Books (Maryknoll, N.Y., 2010). 192 pp., $25.
   "POPE BENEDICT XVI AND THE SEXUAL ABUSE CRISIS: WORKING FOR REFORM AND RENEWAL" by Gregory Erlandson and Matthew Bunson. Our Sunday Visitor (Huntington, Ind., 2010). 207 pp., $12.95.
   UNITED STATES (CNS) – Given the number of books written over the past eight years about the clergy sexual abuse scandal in the United States, one wonders if another one would offer new insights. "When Values Collide" does. Franciscan Father Joseph P. Chinnici was provincial minister in the Franciscans' Province of St. Barbara from June 1988 to January 1997. Four years into that position, he had to deal with allegations that members of his religious community had abused members of the Santa Barbara Boys Choir and St. Anthony Seminary during the '70s.
   The national revelation of the sexual abuse scandal was still 10 years away, as was the Dallas "Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People" and all the initiatives that followed. Thus, Father Chinnici, his community and the board of inquiry that dealt with the abusers and their victims were pioneers. In recounting their work, he tells a story that includes the effects and the affected – staples of stories that would be told a decade later, but which were unique in 1992 and 1993. Posted by Kathy Shaw on October 13, 2010 8:20 AM [2010]

Musical tackles church sex abuse

  [NEW MUSICAL "Mirrors of Desire," by Billy Kirchen. RCC.]    
   Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, http:// www.jsonline.com/ features/religion/ 104192634.html , By Annysa Johnson, Oct. 1, 2010
   MILWAUKEE (WI) -- A new musical by Milwaukee composer-entertainer Billy Kirchen about child sex abuse in the Catholic Church might make it to the stage in Berlin.
   But it won't get a reading at St. Vincent Pallotti Parish in Milwaukee.
   Kirchen and Veronika Nowag-Jones, a German actress and director who says she'll mount his autobiographical "Mirrors of Desire" in Berlin next year, had planned to stage a reading Friday night at the West Side church where Kirchen plays the piano.
   But they moved it to Kirchen's home on short notice after one of St. Vincent's priests took issue with its sometimes graphic content.
   "The church is not a theater. It's a worship space," said Father Greg Serwa, who had fielded a complaint from the mother of one of the actors who had auditioned at the church Thursday night. Posted by Kathy Shaw on October 2, 2010 8:54 AM [2010]

• DAVIE, Edgar; 2010 (© 2007);   Illicit Celibacy and the Deposit of Faith  

  [RCC.]   
   Salem-News, "The Roman Catholic Church Now Faces A New Reformation," http:// www.salem-news.com/ articles/february112010/ catholic_sex_abuse.php ; February 11, 2010
   Illicit Celibacy, Edgar DAVIE PART 2 in this series will discuss these historical changes by Catholic author, Edgar Davie. Please Stay Tuned to Salem-News.com
   Part 1 in a continued series on the Roman Catholic Church's greatest imminent issue: sex abuse.
   NEW YORK, United States – A newly released book alleges the Roman Catholic Church today faces its greatest threat since the Protestant Reformation of the 16th century splintered Christianity.
   The book, Illicit Celibacy and the Deposit of Faith, asserts an unorthodox papal change in Christ's original teaching now requires sexual abstinence for priests and bishops who prove incapable of living celibate lives. This ancient papal requirement of celibacy for priests is now determined by independent Catholic historians and theologians to be illicit, and the source of today's clerical sex abuse scandals.
   Since 2002 the news media has exposed co-ordinated efforts of Catholic bishops to conceal sexual crimes committed against young boys; but it is largely unreported that world wide sexual abuse of adult women and young girls are even more prevalent.
   [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 7:57 AM, February 12, 2010]
http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/carnalbooks.htm#illicit_celibacy_and
   [DETAILS: (Illicit Celibacy and the Deposit of Faith, © 2007, by Edgar Davie, Publisher: CreateSpace (October 8, 2008), http://www.createspace.com , Charleston, South Carolina, 25 August 2010 edition.  ISBN 978-14404-26988.  178 pp +, soft covers, 15·2 x 23 x 1·3 cm (6 x 9 x ½ in), contents, no index, endnotes.]
   [WEBMASTER'S REVIEW: The book needed a better proofreader and some scholarly improvement.
   However, the author has traversed much literature, and seems to have proved that banning marriage of clergymen is quite illicit and unscriptural.
   After the 2nd Vatican Council in the 1960s, the Roman Catholic Church created the office of Permanent Deacons who are married (see p 24).  In the very early Church the office of "deacon" was set up, and they were married men, (1 Timothy 3:8-13) and allowed to re-marry if their wife died (see p 23).  (By the way, at least one deaconess, Phoebe, is mentioned in scripture, at Romans 16:1, if the New Jerusalem Bible 1990 edition and the Revised Standard Version 1971 are to be believed.)  The RCC's "modern restriction against re-marriage for Permanent Deacons is illicit," writes Davie (p 24).
   Pro-celibacy Hellenistic teachers were excommunicated by Pope Hyginus in A.D. 137 and Pope Pius I in A.D. 156 (p 48).
   (As a relevant scripture notes, "If anyone does not know how to manage his own family, how can he take care of God's church?" (1 Timothy 3:5, NIV)
   The contrast between the married clergy that the early Church appointed, and the Catholic Church adopting celibacy for clergy about 1000 years later, is highlighted by the scripture 1 Timothy 4:1-3 (p 24), a better translation of which is: "The Spirit clearly says that in later times some will abandon the faith and follow deceiving spirits and things taught by demons.  Such teachings come through hypocritical liars, whose consciences have been seared as with a hot iron.  They forbid people to marry …" (NIV)
   One can only be amazed that such a passage of scripture could exist side by side with mandatory celibacy in the Catholic Church, Davie writes (p 25).
   "Paul considered mandatory celibacy to be un-Christian because it was a doctrine of many pagan beliefs … Gnostic celibacy was a heretical belief system … spurious secret knowledge … It will be the end of Medieval times, more than a thousand years after Christ, before this practice is successfully mandated for Catholic priests, by hypocrites." (p 25)
   Regarding the words "hypocritical liars" foretold in the Bible text, and Davie's use of the word "hypocrites", later in the book he gives examples of pro-celibacy Popes who had mistresses and children, the sons being promoted and some becoming Popes themselves, while they hypocritically fastened the yoke of celibacy on the rest of the clergy. (see pp 138-9)
   (In addition, the following pro-celibacy decisions are hard to square with the teachings of Jesus of Nazareth, who reportedly said "My yoke is sweet ("easy" in the AV) and my burden light." - Matthew 11:30, Douay version):-
   1022 AD, Synod of Pavia: "Children of priests shall be sold into slavery." (p 114)
   1049 AD, Synod of Rome: "Wives of priests shall be taken as slaves of the Lateran Palace." (p 114)
   1080 AD, Synod of Lillebonne: The fifth canon declares that no priest shall be forced to give anything to the bishop of the diocese beyond their lawful dues, and especially that no money shall be exacted on account of women kept.  (This infamous custom of licensing concubines continued until the sixteenth century.) (p 120)
   1089 AD, Synod of Melfi (under Pope Urban II): "Married priests who ignore the celibacy laws should be imprisoned for the good of their souls, and their wives and children to be sold into slavery and the money accrues to the Church of Rome."  (p 114.Check www.catholicconcerns.com )
   1471 AD, Pope Sixtus IV.  He licensed and taxed the brothels of Rome to pay for the Sistine Chapel.
   This book has many such treasures, including the lowlights of the various pagan infiltrations that finally led to RC clergy of the Latin Rite being banned from marriage.  (The book does not seem to cover the unscriptural deviations by the Orthodox Churches, which still follow the apostolic practice of allowing matrimony for parish clergy, but unscripturally ban marriage for bishops, and also, unscripturally, take no-marriage promises from monks and nuns.) - John Massam, Sep 07, and Nov 19, 2010 ENDS.] [2010]

Sex allegations shock Kerala Church

  [BOOK: Here Is The Heart Of The Priest, autobiography of Shibu KALAPARAMBAN.] [Years. Unnamed Church workers*. RCC. Men, women, children.]  
   CathNews (India), http:// www.cathnewsindia.com/ 2010/09/02/sex-allegations-shock-kerala-church , Sep 02, 2010
   INDIA -- Kerala Church has been rocked by the release of a controversial book which accuses its clergy of a range of misdemeanours and abuses. An official has responded by describing the book as "an all-out attempt to malign the Church."
   Here Is The Heart Of The Priest, the autobiography of Shibu Kalaparamban, a former member of the Vincentian congregation, was officially launched on Sep. 2.
   It alleges that Catholic priests and nuns have broken the vows of chastity and engaged in sexual sins including homosexuality, child abuse and illicit relations. The author narrates confessions he has heard, to substantiate his allegations. [Posted by Kathy Shaw on September 2, 2010 8:06 AM] [2010]

The Trouble with the Pope – A Documentary

  [TELEVISION DOCUMENTARY. RCC. Peter TATCHELL.]      
   GLT News, http:// gltnewsnow.com/ 2010/09/02/ the-trouble-with-the- pope-a-documentary , September 2, 2010
   Channel 4 documentary presented by Peter Tatchell Broadcast Monday 13 September at 8pm
   UNITED KINGDOM -- Human rights campaigner Peter Tatchell presents an hour-long examination of Pope Benedict XVI, broadcast on Channel 4 at 8pm on Monday 13 September, three days before the Pontiff's State Visit to Britain.
   Summarising the documentary, Peter Tatchell said:
   "The programme questions the Pope's policies on a range of issues including his opposition to contraception, condom use and embryonic stem cell research, as well the Pope's mishandling of the child sex abuse scandal, his distortions of the life and ideas of Cardinal Newman and his readmission to the church of the holocaust denier, Bishop Richard Williamson. ..." Posted by Kathy Shaw on September 2, 2010 1:50 PM [2010]

A mother's tale of truth and suffering

  [BOOK: Hell On The Way To Heaven, by Chrissie FOSTER. 2010. R.C.C.]    
   Dandenong Leader, http:// dandenong-leader.whereilive.com.au/ lifestyle/story/a-mothers- tale-of-truth-and-suffering ; by Sam Landsberger, 08:00am, 1 Sep 2010
   AUSTRALIA -- THE story of disgraced parish priest Kevin O'Donnell is a horrific one.
   The convicted pedophile's crimes stretched across five decades, during which he abused several victims. He served 13 years at Dandenong's St Mary's parish and 16 years in Oakleigh.
   It was at Oakleigh that he sexually assaulted primary school students Emma and Katherine Foster. Their mother, Chrissie Foster, has written a book called Hell On The Way To Heaven about that horrific period.
   From 1988 to 1993 the Catholic priest sexually assaulted the girls. Posted by Kathy Shaw on September 1, 2010 8:32 AM [2010]

'Attack on Ratzinger': Italian book assesses Benedict's papacy

  [BOOK: Attacco a Ratzinger: Accuse e scandali, profezie e complotti, by Andrea TORNIELLI and Paolo RODARI. RCC.]  
   National Catholic Reporter (USA), http:// ncronline.org/ blogs/all-things- catholic/attack-ratzinger- italian-book-assesses- benedicts-papacy ; All Things Catholic, by John L Allen Jr, on Aug. 27, 2010
   ITALY -- Friends and foes alike of Pope Benedict XVI concur that he's got an image problem. Where they place the blame for it may differ, but the fact itself seems clear: From a PR point of view, this is a pontificate defined by its train wrecks.
   Cataloguing those train wrecks is the burden of a valuable new book by two of the best Italian vaticanisti going: Andrea Tornielli of Il Giornale and Paolo Rodari of Il Foglio, both of whom also operate widely read blogs -- "Palazzo apostolico" for Rodari and "Sacri palazzi" for Tornielli. Their work is titled Attacco a Ratzinger: Accuse e scandali, profezie e complotti ("Attack on Ratzinger: Accusations and Scandals, Prophecies and Plots"), published in Italian by Piemme.
   The book came out in Italy on Tuesday, and one hopes an enterprising publisher in the States will bring out an English translation quickly. (Let me volunteer here and now: I'd be happy to put together a preface introducing the book, and its authors, to an English-speaking audience.) Posted by Kathy Shaw on August 27, 2010 1:22 PM [2010]

• Among the Flutterers

  [RCC. BOOK The Pope Is Not Gay, by Angelo QUATTROCCHI. 2010.]    
   London Review of Books, http://www.lrb.co.uk/ v32/n16/colm-toibin/ among-the-flutterers , Colm Tóibín, ~ August 16, 2010
   The Pope Is Not Gay, by Angelo Quattrocchi, translated by Romy Clark Giuliani Verso, 181 pp, £8.90, June 2010, ISBN 978 1 84467 474 9
   IRELAND -- In 1993 John McGahern wrote an essay called 'The Church and Its Spire', in which he considered his own relationship to the Catholic Church. He made no mention of the fact that he had, in the mid-1960s, been fired from his job as a teacher on the instructions of the Catholic archbishop of Dublin because he had written a novel banned by the Irish Censorship Board (The Dark), and because he had been married in a register office. Instead he wrote about the great gift of being brought up in the Catholic Church:
   I have nothing but gratitude for the spiritual remnants of that upbringing, the sense of our origins beyond the bounds of sense, an awareness of mystery and wonderment, grace and sacrament, and the absolute equality of all women and men underneath the sun of heaven. That is all that now remains. Belief as such has long gone. Posted by Kathy Shaw at 9:38 AM, August 16, 2010

Robertson questions Pope's legal liability over priest abuse

  [BOOK re RCC: The Case of the Pope: Vatican Accountability for Human Rights Abuse, Geoffrey ROBERTSON, QC, 2010]    
   The Bookseller, http://www.thebookseller.com/ news/125784-robertson- questions-popes-legal- liability-over- priest-abuse.html ; Benedicte Page, August 13, 2010
   Penguin is reviving the "Penguin Special" tradition with a book it describes as a "devastating indictment of the way the Vatican has run a secret legal system that has shielded paedophile priests from criminal trial around the world".
   The Case of the Pope: Vatican Accountability for Human Rights Abuse is written by prominent human rights lawyer Geoffrey Robertson QC and will be published on 8th September, ahead of the Pope's visit to the UK on September 16th.
   The book explores whether the Pope is morally responsible or legally liable under domestic or international law for the negligence that has allowed crimes of child abuse to go unpunished and questions the Vatican's claim to statehood which has given it immunity from scrutiny. Posted by Kathy Shaw at 8:11 AM, August 13, 2010

Clare author in fight for Magdalen justice

  [RCC. PLAY. "Eclipsed," opened 1992]    
   The Clare People, http://www.clarepeople.com/201008072084/Clare-author-in-fight-for-Magdalen-justice.html ; Written by Andy Seamus Hamilton, Saturday, 07 August 2010
   IRELAND -- Clare author Patricia Burke Brogan has vowed to fight to prevent a monument dedicated to the women who were housed in the Magdalen Laundries being torn down.
   The 78-year-old Kildysart woman, who one served for a trainee nun at the Magdalen Laundry in Galway, said removing the monument would be a final insult to the thousands of women who were made into virtual slaves by the state and religious orders.
   Burke Brogan was one of the first people in Ireland to highlight the plight of the women in the Magdalen Laundries when her play Eclipsed was first produced in 1992. She was part of a group who, in consultations with Galway City Council, erected the statue in March of last year. Posted by Kathy Shaw on August 7, 2010 9:05 AM

Abuse 'may badly impair papal legacy'

  [RCC. Book Pope Benedict XVI: The First Five Years, by Michael COLLINS]